The forum is a place to speak about our games, make suggestions, report bugs, and so on. To post a message, you need to be logged in.

neko

is mostly harmless

(schizo superuser)
"we apologise for the inconvenience"
Lives on deep thought
Last login: 120d 13h
Last forum reset: 394d 14h
Membership: never

AoW: removing two borders

Message 1402, 3920d 19h ago. In reply to message 1401.
Calsir wrote:

If looking for balance, it makes sense. However, the main balance issue of European maps is that they have corners and don't allow for flanking manoeuvres to befall on well dug armies on those corners.


Do you think it would be better to have more borders, instead of less??


The bridge between Germany and Scandinavia is very short, and I really don't see how a removal could be justified. As for the Den-UK, its removal would be sensible, as Norway is actually closer to the British mainland and the islands have no bridge to Germany.


AoW is not anywhere close to a simulation anyway. The purpose is to make the map more balanced: in most of the games I am in, the winner is whoever gets Gibraltar.


Since we are talking borders & territories, I have a few opinions and doubts about the world map (45 territories).

1) Why is there a bridge between Siberia and Canada?


To de-emphasise the continents and allow for more varied enclosing possibilities.

2) Since there is a South Africa - Argentina link and a Chile - NZ link, what about adding some sort of Pacific Islands territories linked to Japan, the Philippines and the USA?


We added those connections to avoid the "corner syndrome" of the Europe map. Otherwise, in standard (non-fill-the-map) games, players starting in opposite corners would not interact.

We were thinking to add a "Polynesia" or "Hawaii" territory a few years ago, but Marcuza came up with the current map. I think it could be a nice idea though.

3) Europe is divided into plenty of small territories, the same could be done with the USA... Or at least it could be split into West Coast and East Coast, or even East, South, North West and South West. The same could be done with Canada. This way wars in America could be as interesting as wars in Europe.


We tried to keep the current "main" (whatever that means) states intact. We had to break up Alaska, Siberia and Kamchatka to make the map look better and more playable.


Next time you ask for opinions, think twice about it .


Your opinions are appreciated. I think what we need most is an "average" map, though. Something with about 25-30 territories.
threadpostedtopic startersubject
3594d 14h 3920d 23hneko AoW: removing two borders
|‣ 3920d 20hCalsir AoW: removing two borders
|⌊‣ 3920d 19hneko AoW: removing two borders
| |‣ 3920d 18hSabelkatten AoW: removing two borders
| |⌊‣ 3920d 15hneko AoW: removing two borders
| | ⌊‣ 3920d 14hSabelkatten AoW: removing two borders
| |  ⌊‣ 3920d 13hneko AoW: removing two borders
| |   |‣ 3920d 13hSabelkatten AoW: removing two borders
| |   ⌊—‣ 3920d 1hCalsir AoW: removing two borders
| ⌊——————‣ 3920d 1hCalsir AoW: removing two borders
|        |‣ 3919d 20hneko AoW: removing two borders
|        ⌊—‣ 3918d 15hBlckKnght AoW: removing two borders
|          ⌊‣ 3918d 12hZarby AoW: removing two borders
|           ⌊‣ 3889d 9himdog AoW: removing two borders
|—————————————‣ 3594d 14hneko AoW: removing two borders
⌊——————————————‣ 3594d 14hneko AoW: removing two borders

Copyright

It is understood that in submitting material (like suggestions, comments and proposals on our games) on this forum you are giving up any copyright claims, allowing us at takeaplay.net to freely display, copy, distribute, alter, transform, and build on this material, for the purpose of improving our site and games. We cannot guarantee that all proposals and requests will be developed, of course. In addition, we cannot guarantee that your contribution will be credited esplicitly, though we usually try to do that. However, we intend to keep the forum publicly available, so other players will always be able to know how and when you contributed to this site's growth. It is understood that we will make use of your suggestions to improve the site to the best of our abilities and time available. Your contributions will be rewarded with big smiles, , warm hugs, and no money.