The forum is a place to speak about our games, make suggestions, report bugs, and so on. To post a message, you need to be logged in.


is mostly harmless

(schizo superuser)
"we apologise for the inconvenience"
Lives on deep thought
Last login: 681d 4h
Last forum reset: 687d 1h
Membership: never

New AoW Surrender

Message 1069, 5668d 13h ago. In reply to message 1067.
Silverman wrote:
How about if you surrender in AoW, you automatically drop out of the game?

Thanks for the suggestion I have doubts about your specific proposal, but it's given me an alternative idea, which would partially solve the problem you outlined.

Your suggestion

This would make it almost impossible to be eliminated from the game, since everyone would surrender before being eliminated.

In ELO rating, a distinction was made between surviving and surrendering, so that players have secondary goals besides winning/entering a draw. This helps reduce the "kingmaking" component of the game. This way, losing players will concentrate on surviving, instead of exacting revenge on the player who defeated them.

There is a payoff, as you say, since the game has to slow down and wait for the surrenderers to move.

My proposal.

But your proposal has given me another idea: introduce a second surrendering option. You can either surrender normally, or surrender & automove. With the second option, you voluntarily enter automove in that game.

There is a minor technical problem though. In free-placement games, automovers forfeit new units creation, but in auto-placemnet games automovers still get their units automatically. But I guess we can live with this problem.

Opinions, anyone?
threadpostedtopic startersubject
5667d 3h 5668d 19hSilverman New AoW Surrender
⌊‣ 5668d 13hneko New AoW Surrender
 ⌊‣ 5668d 12hSabelkatten New AoW Surrender
  ⌊‣ 5668d 12hneko New AoW Surrender
   |‣ 5668d 6hShabaka New AoW Surrender
   ⌊—‣ 5667d 14hSabelkatten New AoW Surrender
     ⌊‣ 5667d 12hneko New AoW Surrender
      |‣ 5667d 11hSabelkatten New AoW Surrender
      ⌊—‣ 5667d 11hShabaka New AoW Surrender
        ⌊‣ 5667d 7hneko New AoW Surrender
         ⌊‣ 5667d 4hSabelkatten New AoW Surrender
          ⌊‣ 5667d 3hShabaka New AoW Surrender


It is understood that in submitting material (like suggestions, comments and proposals on our games) on this forum you are giving up any copyright claims, allowing us at to freely display, copy, distribute, alter, transform, and build on this material, for the purpose of improving our site and games. We cannot guarantee that all proposals and requests will be developed, of course. In addition, we cannot guarantee that your contribution will be credited esplicitly, though we usually try to do that. However, we intend to keep the forum publicly available, so other players will always be able to know how and when you contributed to this site's growth. It is understood that we will make use of your suggestions to improve the site to the best of our abilities and time available. Your contributions will be rewarded with big smiles, , warm hugs, and no money.